After a rocky year, Australian musical theatre is having a little bit of a resurgence, with some excellent productions currently on around the country and A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical heading into Sydney with much fanfare. As a jukebox musical, the show focuses on the life of Neil Diamond, telling his story through conversations between an older Diamond (Terence Crawford) and his therapist (Monica Sayers) intertwined with the songs that made his career stand out. There was plenty of energy on opening night as the crowd, many of whom were clearly huge Diamond fans, settled in for a celebration of his music.
The show started by exploring Diamond’s strength as a songwriter, with his song “I’m a Believer” (which was recorded by The Monkees) being one of the early highlights before the show moved into the Diamond songs. The production is heavily centred around both the older Neil Diamond and flashbacks to Diamond’s younger self played by Broadway star Will Swenson. Indeed, Swenson is on stage for the majority of the show, understandably singing a significant number of the musical’s songs. This puts a lot of pressure on the lead and Swenson does a solid job, although the energy did feel a little bit flat at times in the first act. That said, there were some great songs that the audience enjoyed, including “Cherry, Cherry” and of course a rousing rendition of “Sweet Caroline” to end the act, which was executed exceptionally well with a great performance by Swenson and fantastic harmonies behind him to give some extra weight to the song.

The framing device of the psychologist’s office did get a little bit laboured by the end of the first act, feeling like a somewhat tortured plot device to work through the songs. Of course, this is the case with most jukebox musicals in some way but it felt particularly noticeable here. That said, there was more variety in the second act, which gave the ensemble more chance to shine and make something out of what ostensibly felt like a solo show. In this regard, Ashleigh Rubenach was stunning in the role of Marcia Murphey, Diamond’s second wife and really stole the show with a powerful rendition of “You Don’t Bring Me Flowers”, which was one of the highlights of the entire night as her rich tone shone through the Lyric Theatre. There were also some tender moments in the second act which was a nice contrast with the ballad “Play Me” transformed into a duet and executed especially well by Swenson and Rubenach. Arguably, the most powerful moment of the entire show came when Crawford as the older Neil Diamond absolutely nailed his solo with “I Am… I Said”. The raw emotion and power in this number really shone through and perhaps highlighted what was missing in the rest of the show, which felt fairly level and sanitised by comparison.

Swenson sounded remarkably like Diamond and it was quite special to see him really come into his own in the second act as the intensity lifted (and it is always a privilege to see a Broadway star on an Australian stage, although there is a very strong and reasonable counter-argument that there is so much talent in Australia that bringing in performers from Broadway might not always be necessary). The role was a difficult one to pull off and Swenson did so with excellent stamina, especially in the second act as his energy definitely lifted. That said, despite the best efforts of the cast, the show’s material did wear thin by the end of the show with the book perhaps not having as satisfying a plot as some of the other more successful jukebox musicals. The result of this was that the production did feel at times more like a tribute for hardcore Neil Diamond fans than a show designed to bring new audiences in and introduce them to Diamond’s music. This is fair enough (and indeed largely the point of jukebox musicals) but it did mean that the narrative occasionally struggled to hold together as a cohesive piece of musical theatre.

While the ensemble was quite small for this production, Michael Mayer’s direction made them feel like they were always part of the action, with performers popping out from behind the therapist’s chair at multiple points, which was a nice touch. Steven Hoggett’s choreography also helped bring energy and movement to the production, while the band under the musical direction of Nigel Ubrihien provided a fantastic accompaniment throughout. David Rockwell’s set design felt high-budget and varied well while Emilio Sosa’s costumes and Kevin Adams’ lighting were also fantastic. This, combined with the performances, resulted in a vociferous standing ovation at the end of the show as the Neil Diamond-loving audience on opening night absolutely enjoyed every minute.
Ultimately, this is a good show which shines a light on Neil Diamond’s music and is largely well performed by Swenson in the lead and a fantastic ensemble. While this might not be the most complete jukebox musical out there, it is still a fun watch and definitely one to catch before it leaves Sydney.
Rating: ★★★★
A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical plays at the Lyric Theatre until 14 February 2027 before touring nationally. For more information, click here.
All photo credits: Jeff Busby